top of page
  • Writer's pictureTikona Capital

Governance at Scale: Building sustainable startups

Many firms pursue the elusive "hockey stick" growth curve, putting rapid user acquisition and market share ahead of strong governance standards.

Read more on our article on economic times at:

The recent regulatory action against Paytm, an eminent Indian startup, has sparked an important discussion about governance in the fast-paced world of startups. While the company has grown significantly in terms of customers and revenue, the regulatory action illustrates the risks of ignoring sound governance practices amid rapid expansion. Many firms pursue the elusive "hockey stick" growth curve, putting rapid user acquisition and market share ahead of strong governance standards. This emphasis on speed frequently leads to rapid team expansion frequently presents issues such as disoriented identification of roles and tasks, as well as distorted communication routes. This might lead to inefficiencies and misunderstandings within the team. Furthermore, relying on ad-hoc IT infrastructure to suit current needs may overlook long-term factors such as scalability and security, exposing the firm to future risks. Informal decision-making methods, motivated by the founders' intuition or short-term goals, can result in inconsistencies and a lack of strategic direction. Furthermore, prioritizing quick expansion above regulatory compliance may result in legal and reputational issues down the road.

Consequences of Neglecting Governance: While initial growth obscures these flaws, vulnerabilities eventually emerge. Insufficient governance may result in adverse outcomes. Inadequate processes, which lack effective management, can result in duplication of effort, resource waste, and missed deadlines, reducing organizational efficiency. Failure to prioritize the security of technological infrastructure exposes user data to breaches, eroding customer trust and harming the company's brand. Financial irregularities are frequently the result of informal decision-making and insufficient internal controls, which increases the risk of fraud and financial misrepresentation. Noncompliance with regulatory obligations subjects the company to inquiries, fines, and disruptions, threatening its financial stability and operational continuity. Negative media coverage of governance failings can result in regulatory scrutiny, harming the company's reputation and undermining investor confidence and consumer loyalty. Thus, disregarding governance can result in a cascade of effects that weaken the organization's long-term viability and success.

The Paytm Case: A Cautionary Tale: The details surrounding Paytm's regulatory troubles are still unfolding, but the core issue seems to be a lack of robust internal controls and regulatory compliances. This may include security protocols, compliance frameworks, or internal auditing procedures. While strict governance may be difficult for startups at first, it is necessary for developing long-term trust with stakeholders such as regulators, investors, and customers.

The Role of Board and Independent Directors: Boards and Independent Directors have a crucial role to play in ensuring effective governance practices, especially in fast-scaling startups. Some ways to contribute and establish a strong governance framework, boards, particularly those led by independent directors, must cultivate a culture of compliance throughout the firm. This requires raising understanding of legislation and ethical norms, which will develop a commitment to lawful and principled behaviour. Furthermore, duties and responsibilities must be clearly defined. Independent directors play an important role in developing comprehensive board charters and committee structures, which facilitates the assignment of ownership for crucial activities. Furthermore, monitoring risk management practices is critical. Independent directors should ensure that the company has appropriate risk identification, assessment, and mitigation processes in place. Promoting openness and accountability is another important task. They must fight for transparent communication between management and the board, as well as establish robust reporting mechanisms to enhance accountability. Ultimately, Board and independent directors bear the duty of holding management accountable for achieving predetermined objectives and upholding ethical principles, thus safeguarding the organization's integrity and long-term success.

Building Governance at Scale: Foundation for sustainable growth

So, how can startups navigate hyper-growth while establishing strong governance practices? Here are some key strategies:

  • Prioritize early integration of governance principles. Even in their early stages of development, startups should build basic governance frameworks. This could include defining roles and responsibilities, developing ethical standards of behaviour, and establishing basic reporting procedures.

  • A well-balanced board with various skills and experiences can provide valuable advice to entrepreneurs. Independent directors can provide vital insights into risk management, compliance, and long-term viability.

  • Implementing policies and procedures is crucial for a growing firm. This includes accounting practices, human resource rules, and conflict-of-interest guidelines. Formalized processes promote transparency and accountability.

  • Scaling Compliance: Establishing a strong compliance structure early on can prevent future issues. This involves following data privacy rules, financial reporting standards, and sector-specific restrictions.

  • Establishing an ethical culture: Integrity must be a key value of the firm. This entails developing a culture in which employees feel empowered to express their concerns about unethical business activities. Whistleblower protection policies and open communication channels are critical.

  • Investing in Risk Management: Proactive risk management is vital. Identifying possible risks, both internal and external, and developing mitigation plans can help the organization overcome hurdles and achieve long-term success.

  • Continuous learning and improvement: Governance is a dynamic process. Boards and management teams must constantly educate themselves on changing rules and best practices. This could include attending relevant conferences, consulting with experts, and performing frequent internal governance framework evaluations.

  • Maintaining transparency with all stakeholders, including investors, employees, and regulators, is essential. This builds trust and encourages frank discussion of future governance challenges.

To conclude and summarise explosive growth is critical for any startup, but it should never be at the expense of good governance. The Paytm crisis provides a fantastic learning opportunity for the whole startup community. It emphasizes the vital need for a paradigm shift that combines rapid growth with a focus on developing strong governance processes at scale. Startups can lay the groundwork for long-term success by prioritizing and scaling governance alongside other aspects of their businesses. The future of the Indian startup ecosystem rests on cultivating a culture of responsible growth, which is a path we must all embark on together.

5 views0 comments


bottom of page